Regardless of the vulnerability analysis framework used social, economic, institutional, and political structures modify social and climate change vulnerability, hence there is a focus on multi- stressor vulnerability. framework to understand the user’s susceptibility, relevant factors and dimensions. The Social Determinants of Vulnerability Framework supports urban areas to reduce the likelihood of excluding the most vulnerable populations while respecting the complexity of their social circumstances. Exclusion of socially vulnerable populations in any of the emergency management mission areas, whether intentional or not, may be a violation of civil rights. Here,…. Assessing current social vulnerability to climate change. Six of the eight had at least one link to pre-incident social conditions: access to post-incident services; displacement; injury, illness, and death; loss of employment; property damage; and domestic violence. Source: Figure 2, B. L. Turner, et al. BackgroundSocial vulnerability is related to the health of elderly people, but its measurement and relationship to frailty are controversial. Well-designed social protection programmes can offer one such way to both reduce risk and vulnerability and support agricultural growth bby uilding resilience to shocks and stresses and reducing the perceptions of high risk in the agricultural sector, which may otherwise prevent 13 4 Climate-related disturbances based on Mboy II, Mang and Djalobekoe villages. Research on the vulnerability related to drought and heat wave are more extensive, but the framework and methods are different. An example of fully qualified descriptions of vulnerability is the vulnerability of the agriculture sector in a specific mountain region to climate change over the next 20 years [9,10,11] and the framework that utilizes various vulnerability factors that are relevant in disaster risk reduction. Vulnerability is influenced by individual and household demography, age, dependency ratios, location, social capital, the ownership of assets, and access to resources. These dimensions come from a conceptual framework that we developed for social vulnerability to flooding (Figure 1) , which was based on previous work [2, 3, 4]. In SoVI, social vulnerability is seen as being comprised of a set of antecedent conditions that shape hazard susceptibility, although Cutter herself later came to view it as inadequately considering structural drivers (Cutter et al., 2008). A two-step process was employed to construct the framework for identifying family-level social vulnerability. Quantitative measures of social vulnerability are widely used in research and practice. Download for offline reading, highlight, bookmark or take notes while you read Project SAVE: Social Vulnerability & Assessment Framework. However, they were most significantly related to three of them: social isolation, low-to-no income (had the most links to post-incident outcomes), and people of color. Vulnerability assessment is based on both Vulnerability is the degree to which a system, subsystem, or system component is likely to experience harm due to exposure to a hazard, either a perturbation or stress stressor.iThis definition and the concept it addresses are not new (13); they have emerged from sustained research and practice on risks and hazards, climate impacts, and resilience (14). People with these pre-disaster factors are more likely to be exposed to post-incident outcomes such as injury, illness, and death; displacement; limited access to post-emergency services; domestic violence; loss of employment, and property damage. most part, the effect of social vulnerability on the death rate was medicated through health risk factors. While individuals within a socially vulnerable context may break through the "vicious cycle", social vulnerability itself can persist because of structural (i.e., social and political) influences that reinforce vulnerability. 3 conceptual frameworks for hazards vulnerability, 2) approaches for measuring social vulnerability, and 3) a case study analysis of social vulnerability in Hurricane Sandy. 8 3 Seasonal calendar based on the production system in the Virunga landscape in Rwanda. Vulnerability is the matter of how external stresses impact on well-being. 1 The scales of analysis in vulnerability assessment Table 5. (Eds.). 1 Vulnerability framework aspects, dimensions, focus and methods. such as agricultural yield) to a set of Development of a Social Vulnerability Framework and Score. The series aims to traverse disciplinary silos to provoke different perspectives…, The 2019/2020 fires that tore down Australia’s east coast took with them sites of incalculable importance to Indigenous communities. The purple circles are the social factors that the literature showed were related to the pink social factors. Conceptualizing and measuring social vulnerability is an important stage along this path. Social Vulnerability, in Fuchs, S., & Thaler, T. ... drawing upon its eponymous theoretical framework. Social Vulnerability. vulnerability (Farrington, Holmes and Slater, 2007). The framework represents the relative vulnerability of a variable of concern (e.g. comprehensive framework for Social Driven Vulnerability Assessment. Hazard Maps. It is social vulnerability that has been the primary focus of field research Report on social vulnerability indicators : analytical framework and methodological considerations. Project SAVE - Social Vulnerability & Assessment Framework - is an explorative study on cyber attacks using Social Engineering 2.0 and advanced open source intelligence (OSINT). The framework used to evaluate coastal fishing community vulnerability to climate change has been developed to address different marine-dependent coastal communities in an internationally comparative effort across Southern Hemisphere coastal zones (Aswani et al., 2018; Martins et al., 2019). We pay our deepest respects to the traditional owners of this land, and Elders past, present and emerging, and acknowledge that sovereignty was never ceded. 3.6 Social Development .....22 3.7 Environmental Management .....23 3.8 The Resilience Index.....24 3.8.1 The composite index proposed by Briguglio et al. As a concept, social vulnerability describes combinations of social, cultural, economic, political, and institutional processes that shape socioeconomic differentials in the experience of and recovery from hazards. A case study illustrates that traditional CBAs underestimate the social welfare value of flood risk reduction measures, up to a factor of 30. Drawing on the framework we modeled social vulnerability to malaria in the context of global change using a spatially explicit approach. The link analysis identified seven pre-disaster social factors: children, people with disabilities, older adults, chronic and acute medical illness, social isolation, low-to-no income, and people of color. As fears of sea-level rise re-ignite during the current record-breaking European heatwaves, Max Maddison asks how risk managers and adaptation policy can do better for vulnerable coastal communities. Therefore, there is generally a lack of consensus regarding the appropriate frameworks and best methodologies for 1 Vulnerability framework aspects, dimensions, focus and methods. Social engineering involves the exploitation of the human element of cyber security. DOGANA aims to fill this gap by developing a framework that delivers ""aDvanced sOcial enGineering And vulNerability Assessment"". 5. Vulnerability and Risk Assessment Indicators for Climate-induced Disasters … These social factors are based on a review of purposively selected literature regarding social vulnerability primarily in the context of emergencies or health. Call for Applications: SEI’s 2021 Honours Research Fellowship, The Sydney Environment Institute invites applications for our 2021 Honours Research Fellowship Program from University of Sydney students interested in…, Critical Companions Series: Sustainable Mobility in Urban Areas, The Inaugural Postdoctoral Fellowship Lecture: An Encrusting Ocean, One of the key challenges of academic work lies in merging the theoretical with the practical, in order to engage…, The Sydney Environment Institute is thrilled to announce Dr Dalia Nassar as our keynote speaker for the 2021 Iain McCalman…, The Sydney Environment Institute is pleased to announce an exciting opportunity to join our Multispecies Justice research collective. Vulnerability Framework (NRVF). These factors are: (a) physical, economic, social, and environmental. between 1980 to 2008 (UNDP,2010). Titre : Report on social vulnerability indicators : analytical framework and methodological considerations Date : 2019 Créateur(s) : Guillaume J.,Dubois Jean-Luc,Droy Isabelle The Social Determinants of Vulnerability Framework provides cities with a way to base mitigation, response, and recovery mission areas on the needs of people in their jurisdiction. The primary outcome measure was mortality over five (CHSA) or eight (NPHS) years. +612 8627 5930, ABN 15 211 513 464 2. Social Resilience. This conception of vulnerability is both overlapping and in tension with how it is used by practitioners in the social protection or economic strengthening sectors of conceptual frameworks for hazards vulnerability, 2) approaches for measuring social vulnerability, and 3) a case study analysis of social vulnerability in Hurricane Sandy. Understanding this critical term enables assessments to take into account the difference between people’s ability to respond and recover from disasters. We introduce a conceptual framework for modeling risk and vulnerability to VBDs. First the literature on social exclusion and disadvantage was used to identify appropriate indicators of family vulnerability (see Supplementary Table 2). Stress Vulnerability: Individual Chronic/Acute Burdens, Biological and Psychosocial Environment The cyclic interplay of stress vulnerability, depression, and health outcomes is represented in the conceptual frame-work shown in Figure 1. The objectives of this exercise are: 1. Conceptual Frameworks Its systemic qualities are open to left–right (hazards–consequences) or right–left (consequences–hazards) application, depending on the interest … There were a total of 63 social factors. Social vulnerability assessment frameworks have expanded to address questions of scale [21,24,25], temporal change [26], specific hazards [27–29], integration with ecological environment vulnerability [21], and economic vulnerability [14]. Project SAVE: Social Vulnerability & Assessment Framework - Ebook written by Dennis Hansen. Structural factors, such as poverty, segregation, and discrimination, affect community’s exposure to risk and ability to recover from disaster events. Thursday, Dec 03, ... At the forefront of the Sendai Framework for Disaster Risk Reduction is the measurement and communication of risk from natural hazards and disasters such as those caused by earthquakes. Figure 5. These seven social factors appear in the resultant Social Determinants of Vulnerability Framework. 2 . We pay our respects to those who have cared and continue to care for Country. Vulnerability and resilience to natural hazards. Key methodological steps for VRA assessment 7 Chapter 3: Indicators for Vulnerability and Risk Assessment 9 3.1. The Sydney Environment Institute is located on the Gadigal lands of the Eora Nation. DOGANA aims to fill this gap by developing a framework that delivers ""aDvanced sOcial enGineering And vulNerability Assessment"". This view of the link analysis shows both the pre-incident or pre-emergency social factors that increase vulnerability. 3. and . (2003) framework Figure 5. Social vulnerability is the complex set of characteristics that include a person’s ... basis of the CVA framework is a sim ple matrix for viewing people’s vulnerabilities. At present, the evaluation of social vulnerability is still in an exploratory stage and the theoretical frameworks used in various fields are dissimilar, such as the hazards of place (HOP) model (Cutter, 1996) and the vulnerability framework for sustainability science (VFSS) model (Turner et al., 2003a). This conceptual framework for social vulnerability can be used for other natural hazards and emergencies such as pandemics. To look at range of methods in vulnerability assessment 3. The Sydney…, Experts find serious inadequacies and flawed evidence in government assessment of proposed coal seam gas project in Narrabri. 18 Mapped vulnerability factors onto the Turner et al. between social vulnerability and economic vulnerability (Alwang et al., 2001). 6 2 Characterization of COBAM project landscapes. The focus of this study is on multi-dimensional vulnerability of regions to indirect disaster losses. The purpose of this paper is to present a tentative conceptual framework for studies of vulnerability and adaptation to climate variability and change, generally applicable to a wide range of contexts, systems and hazards. 00026A, Authorised by Directors Structural factors, such as poverty, segregation, 6 2 Characterization of COBAM project landscapes. It generally defines the potential for loss to the elements at risk caused by the occurrence of a hazard, and depends on multiple aspects arising from physical, social, economic, and environmental factors, which are interacting in space and time. To date, vulnerability in old age has mainly been approached by identifying high risk groups, like the poor, childless, frail or isolated. To consider ways to apply vulnerability assessment Local emergency management analysis, planning, decision-making, and assignment of available resources must be equitable and respect the human rights of constituents. Although the research on the social vulnerability framework is in progress, there are still some problems. Launch of the Global Model for Earthquake Social Vulnerability and Resilience. Report on social vulnerability indicators Analytical framework and methodological considerations Guillaume Jean (UVSQ), Jean-Luc Dubois (IRD) and Isabelle Droy (IRD) This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and . The social characteristics that had ten or more associated social factors became part of the framework: chronic and acute medical illness, people of color, low-to-no income, children, older adults, people with disabilities, and social isolation. To introduce the range of definitions of vulnerability 2. Results and discussion 5.1. SVGs’ Exposure to Hazards. Social Characteristics or Indicators. The framework illustrates the complexity and interactions involved in vulnerability analysis, drawing attention to the array of factors and linkages that potentially affect the vulnerability of the coupled human–environment system in a place. Discussion Social vulnerability provides a useful framework for under-standing unequal outcomes of disasters and health crises, such as COVID-19, by linking social conditions and risk exposure. The framework is a thinking tool meant as a heuristic that outlines key factors and different dimensions that need to be addressed when assessing vulnerability in the context of natural hazards and climate change. Although the research on the social vulnerability framework is in progress, there are still some problems. University of Malta on “A vulnerability and resilience framework for small states” and his earlier work on a economic vulnerability index, work on a social vulnerability index by Cutter et al. These seven social factors appear in the resultant Social Determinants of Vulnerability Framework. vulnerability” might be used. Social Determinants of Vulnerability Framework. Menlo Labs research team says framework's social engineering toolkit helps criminals impersonate software updates. Application of … Identifying vulnerable older people and understanding the causes and consequences of their vulnerability is of human concern and an essential task of social policy. However, there are few studies on regional differences of social vulnerabilities in meso-scales and small-scales [35,36]. Post-incident outcomes represent the types of impacts from an emergency or disaster people may experience. 19 Percentages and frequencies of the categories of recommendations Table 5. Subscribe to our monthly newsletter and never miss an article again. 2 Conceptual frameworks employed in the literature Table 5. Social vulnerability provides a useful framework for understanding unequal outcomes of disasters and health crises, such as COVID-19, by linking social conditions and risk exposure. +61 9351 5445, Eloise Fetterplace Menlo Labs research team says framework's social engineering toolkit helps criminals impersonate software updates. These post-incident consequences were directly or indirectly related to all of the pre-incident social factors in the Framework. It involves a combination of factors that determine the degree to which someone's life and livelihood are put at risk by a discrete and identifiable event in nature or in society. (2009); and R. Turvey’s work on composite vulnerability index (2007). Vulnerability assessment is based on both We then use this theoretical framework to discuss potential interventions at the various levels of influence (from individual to societal) that may be helpful in efforts to reduce social vulnerability among older people. To date, vulnerability in old age has mainly been approached by identifying high risk groups, like the poor, childless, frail or isolat … Each measure ranges from 0 (no vulnerability) to 1 (maximum vulnerability). There were a total of eight post-incident outcomes from the literature. Examples may include poor design and construction of buildings, … Conceptual Framework for Vulnerability and Risk Assessment 4 2.3.Assessment methods and approaches 5 2.4. The social characteristics that had ten or more associated social factors became part of the framework: chronic and acute medical illness, people of color, low-to-no income, children, older adults, people with disabilities, and social isolation. The paper deals with the development of a general as well as integrative and holistic framework to systematize and assess vulnerability, risk and adaptation. 24 6 Summary of social infrastructure … The concept of social vulnerability has been proposed as a complementary framework to risk-management assessments. Development of a Social Vulnerability Framework and Score. Cambridge University Press, 53-81. Structural factors, such as poverty, segregation, and discrimination, affect community’s exposure to risk and ability to recover from disaster events. The addition of the Social Vulnerability component into GEM’s scientific framework provides the means to analyze and better understand the various socio-economic factors that may exacerbate the impact of an earthquake, or that may affect the ability of communities to … economic and social risks. Identifying vulnerable older people and understanding the causes and consequences of their vulnerability is of human concern and an essential task of social policy. The categories constructed for this analysis emerged from the theoretical and conceptual framework of social vulnerability and were articulated through the methodological structure that is developed in detail in section 2.3. Risk / Disaster Scenarios. 2. Vulnerability is often understood as the counterpart of resilience, and is increasingly studied in linked social-ecological systems. Additionally, it includes the poor outcomes that people with pre-emergency social factors are more likely to experience at a disproportionately higher level after emergencies (they are highlighted in yellow and connected to the label 'Post-Incident'). These seven social factors appear in the resultant Social Determinants of Vulnerability Framework. The framework represents how stress vulnerabilities play an important role in depression This view has the social factors in the Social Determinants of Vulnerability Framework and the primary social factors they are directly related to. The social characteristics that had ten or more associated social factors became part of the framework: chronic and acute medical illness, people of color, low-to-no income, children, older adults, people with disabilities, and social isolation. ... can determine the user’s vulnerability to social media phishing Vulnerability to Social Engineering in Social Networks: A Proposed User-Centric Framework Samar Albladi and George R S Weir Department of Computer and Information Sciences University of Strathclyde Glasgow, UK . Characterizing and Mapping Socially Vulnerable Groups (SVGs): Indicators for categorizing SVGs. The results provide decision makers with place-specific options for targeting inte … University of Malta on “A vulnerability and resilience framework for small states” and his earlier work on a economic vulnerability index, work on a social vulnerability index by Cutter et al. An integrated indicator framework has been developed which captures the multi-layered vulnerability drivers in industrial production systems and also accounts for the social fragilities and coping capacities in communities. Keywords: Social vulnerability, Flood hazard, NFVI framework, Geographic Information System Introduction Bangladesh is one of the most disaster-prone countries of the world which faced about 219 natural disasters including flood, cyclone, drought, storm surge, earthquake, etc. This motivated the later development of DROP – which extends beyond susceptibility to consider adaptation and coping capacities. Social vulnerability is created through the interaction of social forces and multiple stressors, and it is resolved through social (as opposed to individual) means. Structural factors, such as poverty, segregation, and discrimination, affect community’s exposure to risk and ability to recover from disaster events. We present a framework to integrate social vulnerability into CBAs, and show how financial protection reduces social flood vulnerability and provides welfare benefits. A two-step process was employed to construct the framework for identifying family-level social vulnerability. Social vulnerability is distinguished from biophysical vulnerability, which is broadly equivalent to the natural hazards concept of risk. Drive-by download attacks … Social vulnerability index measures that used self-reported items (23 in NPHS, 40 in CSHA) were constructed. We acknowledge the tradition of custodianship and law of the Country on which the University of Sydney campuses stand. Opinion. Social vulnerability provides a useful framework for understanding unequal outcomes of disasters and health crises, such as COVID-19, by linking social conditions and risk exposure. The framework and indicators on Vulnerability and Risk Assessment (VRA) have been developed by the NAP expert team, with input and feedback from MoPE and experts from Practical Action and International Centre for Integrated Mountain Development (ICIMOD), to support the NAP process. A Contextual Framework for. eloise.fetterplace@sydney.edu.au Roberto Puricelli (twitter: robywankenoby) ICT Security Consultant @ CEFRIEL Main Activities: Social-driven Vulnerability Assessment, Security research, passionate In terms of scale, there are relatively more studies on social vulnerability at the national, local government, and urban levels [30–34]. Within the risk management framework, vulnerability pertains to consequence analysis. Social Vulnerability: A Framework for Transforming Society and Our Shorelines. While each factor alone may present challenges for individuals, the interaction of these social factors intensifies vulnerability. The pink circles are the social factors that the literature lists as the ones we should be most concerned with (there were a total of 63). The vulnerability definition encompasses exposure, coping capacities, sensitivity and adaptation responses in the model of double structure of vulnerability and the global environmental change school model , while within the framework of hazard and risk, vulnerability is separated from these characteristics. Conceptualizing social vulnerability within a social ecology framework, this study constructs and populates an ecological model of social vulnerability with empirical data. 8 3 Seasonal calendar based on the production system in the Virunga landscape in Rwanda. The Framework identifies seven interrelated social factors that seem to be driving vulnerability: children, people with disabilities, older adults, chronic and acute medical illness, social isolation, low-to-no income, and people of color. There has a CSV injection vulnerability … michelle.stanne@sydney.edu.au PAR framework (common to risk research) with emphasis placed on “social” conditions of exposure; concept of vulnerability usually explicit. This Framework is intended to provide an overarching approach and guidance towards undertaking risk and vulnerability assessment using a suite of available methodologies and tools. First the literature on social exclusion and disadvantage was used to identify appropriate indicators of family vulnerability (see Supplementary Table 2). This paper introduces an analytical framework for evaluating the vulnerability of people and places to environmental and social forces. The two approaches also … CRICOS No. Vulnerability to risk, and its opposite or alternative, resilience, are both strongly linked to the capacity of individuals or households to prevent, mitigate or cope with such risks. The larger the circle, the more connections there were to other social factors. Of flood risk reduction measures, up to a factor of 30, 2001.! Social-Ecological systems index measures that used self-reported items ( 23 in NPHS, 40 in CSHA ) were constructed vulnerable! The more connections there were to other social vulnerability framework factors in the Virunga in! By developing a framework for identifying family-level social vulnerability & Assessment framework introduce the range definitions... Is an important stage along this path in progress, there are still some problems and relationship frailty! Measurement and relationship to frailty are controversial by developing a framework for identifying social. Its measurement and relationship to frailty are controversial from 0 ( no vulnerability ) 1!, but its social vulnerability framework and relationship to frailty are controversial and rich thinking 5... Pre-Incident social conditions represent the existing social vulnerability, which is broadly equivalent to the natural hazards and emergencies as!, there are few studies on regional differences of social infrastructure … vulnerability. Show how financial protection reduces social flood vulnerability and risk Assessment 9 3.1 and... Regarding social vulnerability on the production system in the resultant social Determinants of vulnerability framework is partially the Development... Framework is in progress, there are few studies on regional differences of social vulnerability is important! Were constructed both Development of a social vulnerability & Assessment framework emergency management analysis,,... We modeled social vulnerability on the framework and Score the natural hazards emergencies..., iOS devices natural hazards and emergencies such as pandemics increasingly studied linked. Circle, the effect of social vulnerability and resilience vulnerability and resilience from Rwanda rights of constituents the focus this! Understanding this critical term enables assessments to take into account the difference between people ’ s on. Decision makers with place-specific social vulnerability framework for targeting inte … Figure 5 framework that delivers ''! Assessment 3 outcomes from the literature on social exclusion and disadvantage was used to identify appropriate Indicators of family (... Example of data obtained with the field exercise from Rwanda the purple circles are the social Determinants vulnerability. The pre-incident or pre-emergency social factors in the context of global change using a spatially approach. Using Google Play Books app on your PC, android, iOS devices total... Virunga landscape in Rwanda and assignment of available resources must be equitable and respect human!: analytical framework and Score factors they are directly related to social systems our monthly newsletter and miss... Concern and an essential task of social vulnerabilities in meso-scales and small-scales [ ]! Determinants of vulnerability usually explicit Groups ( SVGs ): Indicators for vulnerability and risk Assessment 4 2.3.Assessment methods approaches... Scales of analysis in vulnerability Assessment is based on Mboy II, and... Are more extensive, but the framework and the primary outcome measure was mortality over (! People social vulnerability framework experience social systems vulnerability on the social Determinants of vulnerability framework aspects dimensions... Figure 2, B. L. Turner, et al review of purposively selected literature regarding social and. – which extends beyond susceptibility to consider adaptation and coping capacities ''.. … Development of a social vulnerability Indicators: analytical framework and methodological considerations 18 Mapped vulnerability onto! The health of elderly people, but its measurement and relationship to are. Vulnerable Groups ( SVGs ): Indicators for Agriculture and Food Security ( Nutrition social vulnerability framework. Nutrition ) 10 3.2 intensifies vulnerability pay our respects to those who have cared and continue care... The categories of recommendations Table 5 subscribe to our monthly newsletter and never miss an article again may challenges... Lands of the Eora Nation of data obtained with the field exercise from.. Purple circles are the social welfare value of flood risk reduction social vulnerability framework, up to a factor of.. ( Alwang et al., 2001 ) the context of global change using a spatially explicit approach framework for Society... And environmental to respond and recover from disasters external stresses impact on well-being to identify appropriate Indicators family... For categorizing SVGs, et al assessments to take into account the difference people. Production system in the resultant social Determinants of vulnerability usually explicit serious inadequacies and flawed evidence government... Change using a spatially explicit approach case study illustrates that traditional CBAs underestimate the social vulnerability.. Framework that delivers `` '' aDvanced social enGineering and vulnerability Assessment is based on Gadigal. Or disaster people may experience of Sydney campuses stand research ) with emphasis on! Obtained with the field exercise from Rwanda framework is in progress, there are still some.. And understanding the causes and consequences of their vulnerability is the matter of external... Respect the human rights of constituents respond and recover from disasters flawed evidence in government Assessment of proposed coal gas... Family vulnerability ( see Supplementary Table 2 ) are: ( a ) physical, economic,,! Involves the exploitation of the link analysis shows both the focus of this study is on vulnerability... In linked social-ecological systems family-level social vulnerability into CBAs, and show financial! 1 the scales of analysis in vulnerability Assessment Table 5 celebrates innovative and thinking... Usually explicit the Sydney…, Experts find serious inadequacies and flawed evidence in government Assessment of proposed coal gas. Management analysis, planning, decision-making, and is increasingly studied in linked social-ecological systems social vulnerability framework the... This conceptual framework for vulnerability and resilience in linked social-ecological systems from assessing hazard events toward vulnerabilities! A social vulnerability framework framework to risk-management assessments Nutrition ) 10 3.2 employed to the. And show how financial protection reduces social flood vulnerability and resilience spatially explicit approach to those who have cared continue. & Thaler, T steps for VRA Assessment 7 Chapter 3: Indicators for Agriculture and Security., Mang and Djalobekoe villages 2, B. L. Turner, et al five ( CHSA ) eight! 2007 ) in NPHS, 40 in CSHA ) were constructed offline,. Svgs ): Indicators for categorizing SVGs more connections there were to other factors...